Bureaucracy collapsed due to politicization- Dr Akbar Ali Khan

Staff Correspondent

The bureaucracy in the country has collapsed due to its politicisation, eminent economist Dr Akbar Ali Khan said yesterday (Saturday).

“When politics and bureaucracy are mixed and politicians hold the absolute power, bureaucracy cannot work properly,” he said while delivering a public lecture. “Such a politicisation becomes visible during promotions. If you are in the government's good book, then you will get promoted...,” he added.

“Bangladesh is the only country where promotion takes place although there is no vacancy in that post,” said Dr Akbar, a former top bureaucrat.

The Department of Public Administration of Dhaka University organised the lecture on the campus. In the lecture, the former adviser to a caretaker government said politicisation and more than necessary posts in the administration, such as the post of additional secretary, create delay in the administrative work.

Pointing to the provision of the public order that allows the government to sack any official who has served more than 25 years without showing any reason, Akbar said, “In such a situation, it is difficult to make bureaucracy effective.”

About delay in the administrative work, he said a file has to pass eight to nine hands, from the section assistant to the minister, to accomplish a task. As a result, around five additional days get wasted.

“Let's say, all the officials are honest, nobody takes any bribe. But creating five extra posts [in the administration] delays decision making at least for five days,” he said.

The country has more than 600 additional secretaries and every ministry has at least two to three such secretaries. Some even have more than 20, he said. The posts of additional secretary delay the office work in terms of decision-making, he added.

In the lecture, he also stressed the need for reforming the judiciary so that the trial proceedings can be finished swiftly. “The main reason behind the delay in trial proceedings is the British law, which we follow. It is based on lawyers, where one party will win and another will lose. But the lawyers do not want to dispose of the suits,” Dr Akbar said.

• Courtesy: The Daily Star/ Jan 21, 2018

A few reasons that let rice prices go through the roof

Opinion

NO SIGN of decline in rice prices even after the harvest of the aman began amidst record import of rice remains worrisome. Rice prices shot up in 2017 after heavy rainfall and flooding that had an adverse impact on rice farming. The government is reported to have imported 2.38 million tonnes of rice in the current financial year, said to be the highest keeping to the statistics since 1987 that are available. Yet, this could, as the Trading Corporation of Bangladesh says, hardly change the price situation. The coarse variety of rice, which sold for prices between Tk 35 and Tk 38, now sells for prices between Tk 44 and Tk 46 a kilogram. The medium variety, which sold for prices between Tk 40 and Tk 45, now sells for prices between Tk 48 and Tk 56 while the fine variety, which sold for prices between Tk 48 and Tk 56, now sells for prices between Tk 64 and Tk 68 a kilogram. With the situation continuing for quite some time — the rice import and the harvest of aman failing to create the expected impact on the market, it has left consumers to believe that there has been no one to look after the interest of consumers.

While retailers put the situation down to the low outturn of aman and foggy weather which hampered the drying of the rice that has been harvested, husking mill owners could give out no reason for such high prices as they claim the prices, mainly of the coarse varieties, to have declined on the wholesale market, especially over the past few weeks. The situation as it stands reeks of market manipulation, which the government seems to have failed to stem. While experts say that rice has not been in short supply and there are, therefore, no reasons for prices to keep going up, consumer rights campaigners say that the government has failures in rice market management. As the government has not been able to adequately intervene into the market, rice prices have remained vulnerable to manipulation. This was compounded by the poor stock of rice, which stood at 0.58 million tonnes, as the Directorate General of Food says, in the middle of January. Experts think that the stock should have more than a million tonnes of rice to cushion off any trouble. Rights campaigners also blamed the government’s injudicious move of increasing the procurement price, of aman at Tk 39 from Tk 35 a kilogram, when the rice prices have already been high. This is thought to have sent out a wrong signal for the traders that prompted them to increase prices.

If any of these propositions discussed and debated proves to be true, what it gets down to, in the end, is the government’s failure in rice market oversight and management, and policy and procedural flaws. The government, under the circumstances, must immediately set issues, which have so far been on the wrong track, right to prove its commitment to the citizens. 

• Courtesy: New Age, Jan 21, 2018

Sand lifting threatens Faridpur river

Correspondent, Faridpur

Illegal lifting of sand from the Chandana river at Char Magchami in Madhukhali upazila poses a threat to agriculture and the people living along the river.

During a recent visit, this correspondent found lifting of sand by a dredger machine was going on and the sand is used in filling a ditch at Badhuli Khalkula Hafezia Madrasa under Jamalpur union in Baliakandi upazila of Rajbari. 

A sand worker, seeking anonymity, said Jamalpur Union Parishad Chairman Younus Ali has been lifting the sand for the last two weeks.

On condition of anonymity, a number of local people said Younus, also President of the madrasa managing committee, has been lifting the sand for the last 15 days which is posing a threat of erosion anytime. “We told the chairman about the river erosion caused by the illegal sand lifting, but he did not pay any heed,” they added.

Refuting the allegation, Younus said he has no idea about who was lifting the sand and will take necessary step to stop it.

Baliakandi Upazila Nirbahi Officer (UNO) Masum Reza said as the area is under the jurisdiction of Madhukhali upazila he informed the UNO concerned.

• Courtesy: The Daily Star Jan 21,2018

Religious, Ethnic Minorities: Rise in attacks due to culture of impunity

Staff Correspondent

A culture of impunity and delay in trials for attacks on religious and ethnic minority people were behind the rise in such incidents, eminent rights activist Sultana Kamal said yesterday (Friday).

“The state had to play a strong role in this regard, but it could not carry out the role,” she told a conference at the Jatiya Press Club.

The number of such incidents could have been brought down had the attackers been identified and put on trial immediately, she observed.

Bangladesh Mohila Oikya Parishad, an associate body of Bangladesh Hindu Bouddha Christian Oikya Parishad, organised the second triennial conference.

Rana Dasgupta, general secretary of Bangladesh Hindu Bouddha Christian Oikya Parishad, inaugurated the conference which focused on establishing equal rights of the women from the religious and ethnic minority communities.

According to a recent report of the oikya parishad, more than 30,000 people from these communities became victims of at least 1,004 incidents of violence across the country last year. Of them, over 104 were either murdered or found dead and 325 injured.

Besides, at least 15 women were gang-raped, 18 were raped, and 11 became victims of attempted rape that year, said the report prepared based on newspaper reports.

Terming such communal attacks barbarous, Sultana said, “On average, three incidents of violence took place every day last year. If there was no culture of impunity and delay in trials, such incidents would not have happened.”

The main objective of the country's independence was to ensure the rights of all citizens irrespective of race, religion and cast as mentioned in the constitution, she told the programme while speaking as the chief guest.

“But the religious and ethnic minority people and those having differing views face severe violence from a group of people. It seems Bangladesh has been shrinking gradually [due to the activities of that group].” The minority community members, especially the women, should get united and raise their voice to resist such violence and ensure their rights, said Sultana, also an adviser of a former caretaker government.

Rana Dasgupta said communal forces and militancy have emerged in the country. “Many political parties formed unities with them at different times due to politics of vote.” Even the textbooks have been communalised under pressure from the forces, he complained, adding that thousands of people did not lay down their lives during the Liberation War in 1971 for these reasons.

The Mohila Oikya Parishad President Jayanti Roy, General Secretary Priya Shaha and its former president Sabitri Bhattacharya also spoke, among others.

• Courtesy: The Daily Star Jan 20, 2018

LPG price policy falls apart, people paying more

Energy Division had initiated a move three years ago to formulate a LPG pricing policy to keep exorbitant price at bay. 

However, the effort remained futile for undue influences by vested interest groups, reports UNB. 

Amid such a policy vacuum, each LPG bottle (12.5 kg) is now being sold in the local market at Tk 1100-1200 whereas, a committee of the government's Energy Division had calculated that no way the price should cross Tk 730. 

Three years back Energy Division moved to formulate the LPG pricing policy at government's dictate as the latter was trying to promote LPG as cooking gas as a replacement of piped natural gas, distributed by the state-owned Titas and other gas companies in Dhaka and elsewhere. 

Identifying high market price of LPG as a barrier for its promotion as alternate cooking gas, Energy Division held stakeholders' meeting with the participations of the LPG marketing companies belonging to both private and public sectors. 

Taking their opinion into consideration, Energy Division formed a committee to draft a formula to fix the LPG price at the retail market. 

The committee, headed by the then additional secretary Kazi Zebunnesa Begum, found that after meeting all expenses a 12.5 kg LPG bottle should not be sold at above Tk 703 and no private company should sell that at price more than Tk 730 in retail. 

The committee, comprising of representations from both public and private sectors, made a recommendation to introduce labelling of maximum retail price (MRP) on the surface of LPG bottle and make it mandatory for traders to sell it at the fixed price. 

Big players blocked the move

"But some big players in the LPG sector blocked the move by their influence on the political level", said a senior official at the Energy Division preferring anonymity. 

Introducing a permanent formula to fix the price was also a vital recommendation of the committee. "But the recommendation could not be implemented due to opposition from some major companies," he told UNB.

A good number of companies, including two from public sector, are operating in the LPG business in the country. The major private operators are Omera, Bashundhara, Beximco, Total Gaz, Klean Heat, Jamuna, Orion, Bin Habib, Super Gas (TK Gas). 

Disagreeing with the concept of LPG price fixing, Jakaria Jalal, general manager (strategic planning), of Bashundhara LPG, said it will be unrealistic to fix the LPG price for retail market as the price of the product is linked with the oil price in global market where it fluctuates all the time. 

He rather put the onus on some unfavourable policies pursued by government that pushed the LPG prices up. As examples, he cited high license fee of Bangladesh Energy Regulatory Commission (BERC) and limitation in import of over 3,000 MT LPG vessel. 

Energy Division Additional Secretary Muhammed Ahsanul Jabbar, now in-charge of LPG related affairs, admitted about the inordinate delay in finalising the LPG price policy. "We're working on it and the retail pricing formula will be in place within next six months," said the official. 

Contacted State Minister for Power and Energy Nasrul Hamid expressed his frustration over the delay. "I'm not happy with overall performance of Energy Division as it achieved only nine per cent in ADP implementation", he told UNB. 

Industry insiders noted that in spite of high price, LPG market is growing gradually in Bangladesh. In 2016, total LPG market in Bangladesh was around 400,000 MT and the demand is shot up to over 500,000 MT in a year’s time.

• Courtesy: The Financial express Jan 19, 2018

Bangladesh slips one step on visa-free travel rights

Stands even behind war-torn S Sudan in Henley & Partners index based on worth of passports

FE Report

Bangladesh slips one step down in a latest global passport index, now standing even behind war-torn South Sudan in ensuring their citizens' visa-free foreign travels.

Bangladeshi passport is now in 96th position in the world in terms of visa-free access its holders can enjoy, down from the 95th it secured last year as per the ratings done by Henley & Partners.

The country has also suffered the largest individual decline of any nations, dropping 23 ranks on the index since 2008.

Of the 199 countries featured in the index, only 10 countries got the ranking as having less visa-free access around the world than Bangladesh's while at least 185 having more visa-free access than Bangladesh's rating.

The index also shows that even relatively isolated countries like North Korea or war-ravaged ones like South Sudan enjoy more visa-free access in the world than Bangladesh does.

As per the findings, the number of countries where Bangladeshi passport-holders can enjoy visa-free access remained unchanged as 38 since last year.

However, a number of countries like Sri Lanka and South Sudan which were equal or behind Bangladesh in the index just a year ago now apparently offer more freedom of movement than Bangladeshi passports.

Comparative annual data from the index show that the number of countries Bangladeshis can travel sans visa stood at 28 back in 2006.

Although the number rose to a high of 42 countries back in 2010 and again in 2014, it had witnessed a steady decline in recent years.

During the same period (2006 to 2018), India's visa-free access has risen from 25 to 49 while for Sri Lanka, it increased from 22 to 41.

Even people of a tiny landlocked country like Bhutan do have much more freedom of flying to foreign countries than those of Bangladesh.

Published since 2005, The Henley Passport Index does the ranking of all the passports of the world according to the number of countries their holders can travel to visa-free.

The rankings are based on exclusive data from the International Air Transport Association (IATA), which maintains world's largest and most comprehensive database of travel information, and is enhanced by 'extensive in-house research'.

Germany retains the top spot in the Henley Passport Index for the fifth year in a row, offering its citizens access to 177 countries. The country is closely followed by Singapore which has visa-free access to 176 countries.

Meanwhile, Pakistan, Syria, Iraq, and Afghanistan occupy the bottom four ranks in the 2018 index, each having visa-free access to 30 or fewer countries.

"There is no denying that a global mobility divide exists," says Dr. Christian H. Kälin, Group Chairman of Henley & Partners.

"Nonetheless, only a small minority of countries on the Henley Passport Index lost visa-free access in 2018. By and large, countries either improved or maintained their access compared to 2017," he added.

"These findings reflect the fact that, while certain countries are tightening their borders, most are in fact becoming more open, as they seek to tap into the immense economic value that tourism, international commerce and migration can bring."

Dr. Kälin also pointed out that the countries that offer the most credible citizenship-by-investment programmes in the world consistently perform strongly in the indexing.

"More governments than ever before are embracing residence- and citizenship-by-investment programs as a means of stimulating economic development and growth, and an increased number of wealthy and talented individuals are looking to diversify their citizenship portfolios to give themselves and their families greater international opportunity, travel freedom, stability, and security".

• Courtesy: The Financial Express Jan 20, 2018

Mobile internet access in BD lower than South Asian average

GSMA top executive tells FE

Ismail Hossain  

Alasdair Grant  - Head, Asia Pacific at Global System for Mobile Communication Association (GSMA). 

The mobile telephony sector must take data protection seriously if it wants be at the heart of digital community, a top executive of global telecom industry has said.

"The mobile industry will not be heart of digital community if it does not take user's data protection and trust factor seriously," the head of Asia Pacific at Global System for Mobile Communication Association (GSMA) Alasdair Grant said.

The users need to trust operators, he said, adding without trust, financial inclusion, mobile financial services and other digital communication will not be successful.

"Traditionally, we have seen people are reluctant to use e-commerce and online transaction fearing personal data breach, if this happens with mobile industry as well, the digital community will not reach its target."

He talked to the FE while in Dhaka to attend Bangladesh National Dialogue on M4SDG: Mobile Services to Accelerate SDG Achievement in Bangladesh.

On the sidelines of roundtable, he said Bangladesh had lagged behind in mobile internet penetration in terms of regional competitors.

"One-third of Bangladeshi population have mobile internet access, while the average mobile internet usage rate in South Asia is currently 38 per cent. So it is a little bit behind," he said.

He sees digital literacy and, in broader terms, literacy is a big constraint on the way to expanding the market.

"A lot of people can't send text messages, a lot of people have difficulty in using application for using internet, what we found around the world, digital literacy is a big impediment, " he said. "Currently there is 90 per cent 3G coverage in Bangladesh but mobile internet penetration is only one third of the population. This is because lower rate of literacy."

"There are a number of roadblocks we have in the Bangladesh market. Literacy, data price and availability of spectrum, the rate of taxes on the mobile industry are among them."

He said taxes on the mobile industry are one of the highest in the region, which is 45 per cent. The rate of taxes should be reduced.

"We also would like to see some progress in national telecom policy. We want a robust set of principles and regulations for the industry."

On the network side, he said, he wants to see some flexibility in sharing their network with each other to reduce the cost of deployment.

He said there must be a spectrum roadmap and the telecom regulator needs to release more spectrum for stronger network.

He said Bangladesh has released much smaller amount of spectrum capacity than those in neighbouring countries.

He said the mobile industry is highly capital-intensive industry, so they need to know how much and when and what investment they would do.

He said that the operators are making very large network commitment in Bangladesh, seeing the country as a huge growing market.

"Only one third of population are using internet that situation really should be changed here."

About security, he said that GSMA works closely with operators and also with the national governments and cyber security experts.

"The number of machines and devices connected to internet will dramatically increase in the near future. Therefore, the need for security and risk associated with security will be greater," he said, adding that the industry needs to be ready to encounter that.

The GSM Association (commonly referred to as 'the GSMA') is a trade body that represents the interests of mobile network operators worldwide.

• Courtesy: The Financial Express, Jan 20, 2018

LOWERING MINIMUM AGE - Govt draws huge flak from FFs

Mohiuddin Alamgur

The government decision of lowering to twelve and a half years the minimum age to be eligible as a freedom fighter has drawn huge flak from freedom fighters.

They find the decision ‘unnecessary’, ‘illogical’ and ‘unfortunate’ and fear it will only add to the debate over status and listing of freedom fighters.

Freedom fighters as well as 1971 liberation war organisers, talking to New Age, have observed that yet another change in the age limit for becoming freedom fighters will lead only to an increased number of fake freedom fighters.

They think that this ‘debatable’ decision will undermine the position of freedom fighters in society.

The government on January 17 issued a gazette notification fixing the minimum age at twelve and a half years, down from 13, to be eligible for becoming a freedom fighter. People who were at least 12 and a half years old on November 30, 1971 will be eligible for applying for inclusion in the list of freedom fighters.

‘This decision is illogical and unacceptable,’ freedom fighter Zafrullah Chowdhury said, adding, ‘It is really absurd as the next government may lower it to 10 years.’ 

‘Situation has reached such a level that everyone who was born in 1971 should be considered freedom fighter as the foetus inside womb had inspired the mother and after birth the baby inspired all throwing its hands and legs,’ said Gonoshasthaya Kendra trustee Zafrullah, with sarcasm in his tone.

The government issued gazette notification in line with a decision made at a meeting of Jatiya Muktijoddha Council in October last year. It on June 19 that year issued a gazette notification fixing 13 years as the minimum age for an eligible freedom fighter. In 2014, the minimum age limit was fixed at 15 years.

Dhaka University professor emeritus Aniszuzzman said that he was not aware of the reasons for lowering the minimum age limit for a freedom fighter. ‘But it is really unfortunate that debate over minimum age limit, definition and list of freedom fighter still exists in society,’ he regretted.‘I do not see any way out of this debate. We already got into the debate, which haunted us for long,’ said Professor Aniszuzzman.

The nation is still in dark about the actual number of freedom fighters as successive governments could not prepare a comprehensive list in the past 46 years and provided differing figures.

Jatiya Muktijoddha Council initiated the latest move in October 2014 to have an authentic list of freedom fighters but was yet to complete scrutiny of over 1.42 lakh applications for inclusion in the list. The government at that time had set 15 years during the liberation war as the minimum age limit for being considered a freedom fighter.

‘Changes of minimum age limit show that government is still in indecision, which created chaos,’ said Communist Party of Bangladesh president Mujahidul Islam Selim, also a freedom fighter. ‘It is really unfortunate that such thing is happening as regards the freedom fighters, who should get the due of all,’ he said, blaming successive governments for the current situation.

Former Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangsad Kendriya Command Council chairman Abdul Ahad Chowdhury criticised the decision terming it ‘illogical’.

‘Freedom fighters as well as people have not taken the decision positively as they do not find any logic for it,’ he stressed. 

‘Fake freedom fighters would get advantage from the decision,’ Ahad said.

‘It is true that some boys took part in the liberation war and Jatiya Muktijoddha Council can make special arrangements for them following due legal procedures,’ Ahad proposed, opposing wholesale lowering of age limit for all freedom fighter.

Sector Commanders Forum Liberation War 1971 secretary general Harun Habib also proposed a special provision for juvenile freedom fighter whose percentage was nominal. ‘It is really an unfortunate decision and such things might give negative impression about freedom fighters in society,’ he warned.

Freedom fighter and cultural activist Nasiruddin Yousuff, however, said that the government decision of lowering minimum age was acceptable as it was taken to include all freedom fighter in the listing process.

Rights activist and freedom fighter Sultana Kamal refused to make any comments regarding government’s decision to lower the minimum age to be eligible as a freedom fighter.

• Courtesy: New Age/Jan 20, 2018

Human rights situation continues to decline

Shakhawat Hossain

At least 139 people fell victim to ‘crossfire’ and 86 to enforced disappearance in Bangladesh in 2017, says annual report of the human right organisation Odhikar.

The Odhikar report which was released on Friday last, also said that 59 people ‘died’ in jail custody and 77 people were killed in political violence last year. Besides, 783 women and girls  became victims of rape, 242 were subjected to sexual harassment, 256 women became victims of violence for dowry and 52 were injured in acid attacks during  2017.

The report said 13 apparel workers were killed, 362 were injured and 3141 were terminated from their jobs. Besides, 82 workers of other sectors were killed and 80 others were injured in 2017.

The Odhikar report said 32 citizens were arrested under notorious ICT Act ( Information and Communication Technology Act) , one journalist was killed, 24 injured, 9 were assaulted and 11 journalists were threatened in 2017. 

It also reported that Indian border security force (BSF), killed 25 Bangladeshis injuring 29. Another 28 Bangladeshi citizens were victims of abduction by BSF in last year. 

The annual report of 2017 is the outcome of a compilation and analysis of the monthly human rights situation monitoring reports published every month in 2017.

The Odhikhar  report  illustrates  systematic  violations  of civil  and  political  rights, including  violations   of  the  rights  to  freedom  of  expression, a  shrinking   democratic   space   and dysfunctional justice   delivery   system due   to politicization in  the  judiciary; and  deprivation  of  the  right  to  life.  

Odhikar  says,  human rights violations continued in an endemic form in 2017, since  the rule of an authoritarian regime has been in operation in Bangladesh 

If  the state  is  not  established  on  a democratic  foundation, its  potential  political  target  cannot  be  achieved,  the  report  says  recalling  that  Bangladesh has  ratified  eight out  of  nine  core  international  Conventions  and  Treaties,  including  the  International  Covenant  on  Civil  and  Political  Rights  (ICCPR),  Convention  against  Torture  and  Other  Cruel,  Inhuman  or  Degrading  Treatment  or  Punishment  (UN CAT).  It has  also  ratified  the  Rome  Statute  of  the  International  Criminal  Court.

The human rights situation of Bangladesh in 2017 remained   detrimental due   to   the   failure of   implementation of the   mandatory obligations of these treaties. The Awami League has remained in power since 2009, thus the background of the human rights situation of 2017 is the continuation of the 2009 human rights record, says the report.

Furthermore, another  trend, of  shooting  in  the  leg or  knee capping by  the  security  forces, was added to  the  list  of human  rights  abuses since  2011, of  which  a large  majority  of  victims  were  leaders  and  activists  of  the  opposition  political  parties.

On many occasions, the ordinary citizens became victims during political violence. In 2017, the government imposed various repressive  laws, targeted  at dissenters  and  also  suppressed  and  harassed  the  opposition  and people  belonging  to  alternative beliefs and ideology, by accusing  them  of different  criminal acts, including  sedition and   defamation.  

The  Adhikar mentions  that  accurate   and   independent   news reports were barred from publication due to the government’s imposition of restrictive policies and by putting pressure on the media  by different  ways  and  means;  and  in  most  cases  journalists  were  forced  to  maintain  self-censorship  while  publishing  reports.

The  government  controls  most  of  the  media;  particularly  the  electronic  media,  which  are  mostly owned or controlled by supporters or members of the ruling party and closed down some  pro-opposition  electronic and  print  media.  Many journalists were attacked by criminals backed by and supporters of the ruling party while performing their duty during this period.

In  2017,  surveillance  and  monitoring  on  social  media  by  the government was  wide and the  Information  and  Communication  Technology  Act  2006  (amended  2009,  2013)  and the  Special  Powers  Act  1974  were imposed  against  people who were critical of the decisions and activities of  those in high positions of the government.

• Courtesy: Weekly Holiday/Jan 19, 2018

অর্থমন্ত্রী অন্ধ হলেই প্রলয় বন্ধ হবে না!

 এ হোসেইন 

সরকার দেশে উন্নয়নের মেলা বইয়ে দিচ্ছেন। ঝড়ো প্রচার চলেছে দুর্বার গতিতে। তবে সিপিডি যে সব তথ্য-উপাত্ত দিয়েছে তাতে দেখা যায়, ধনী অারও বিত্তবান, গরিব অারও গরিব হয়ে যাচ্ছে। ব্যাপার‌টা অর্থমন্ত্রী ‘রাবিশ’ বলে উড়িয়ে দিয়ে অন্ধ বনলেই  প্রলয় বন্ধ হবে না।

তবে সরকারের জন্য এটি মাথাব্যথা বলে গণ্য না-ও হতে পারে। 

বাংলাদেশের অামলা জগত প্রায়ই প্রবৃদ্ধি অার উন্নয়নের ব্যাপারটা গুলিয়ে ফেলেন। অার তাদের অনুগত মিডিয়াও একই তরিকা অনুসরণ করে। তবে অর্থনীতিবিদেরা বেশ কিছুকাল ধরেই এমনকি সরকারের নিজস্ব উপাত্ত ধরেই সরকারকে চ্যালেঞ্জ জানিয়ে অাসছেন। উদাহরণ স্বরূপ, ঢাকা বিশ্ববিদ্যালয়ের শিক্ষক এম এ তসলিম খানাওয়ারি অায়-ব্যয়-এর জরিপের উপাত্ত উদ্ধৃত করে সম্পত্তির ব্যাপক সম্প্রসারণের বিষয়টি  চ্যা‌ল‌েঞ্জ করেনন। তিনি সরকারি পর্যায়ে তৈরি ( যেমন বিবিএস-এর  উপাত্ত) অন্যান্য ত‌থ্যকে চ্যালেঞ্জ জানিয়েছেন। তাঁর দাবি পারিবারিক অায় ২০১০-২০১৬ মেয়াদে বরং  ১১ শতাংশ কমেছে। অথচ বাংলাদেশ পরিসংখ্যান ব্যুরোর উপাত্ত বলছে প্রকৃত জাতীয় অায় ৪২ শতাংশের ও বেশি বেড়েছে। প্রফেসর তসলিম দাবি করছেন, প্রবৃদ্ধির উপকার সাধারণ মানুষের ঘরে যাচ্ছে না।

তবে সরকার তো তাদের নিজের দেওয়া উপাত্তকে অস্বীকার করতে পারেন না। উপেক্ষা করছেন। কেননা, এটা মেনে নেওয়া তাদের দরকার নেই। কেননা উন্নয়ন হচ্ছে সরকার ও ধনীদের মধ্যে যোগাযোগের একটা চক্র। দরিদ্র সেখানে কোনো ফ্যক্টর নয়। তাদের কাছে কেবল এগ্রিগেটসই  ধর্তব্য। বিত্ত যাদের অাছে তারাই গণ্য, গরিব একান্তই নগণ্য।

সিপিডি বলেছে  দূর্বত্তায়িত ব্যাঙ্কিং খাতে সঙ্কট, মূল্যস্ফীতি, অাকাশমূখি অামদানি, কম রপ্তানি, অপর্যাপ্ত রেমিট্যান্স, ব্যাঙ্কে দলীয় অাধিপত্য ও রাস্ট্রীয় তহবিল লোপাট ইত্যাদির কারণে অর্থনীতি  চাপে রযেছে।

তাই দেশের অর্থনৈতিক ব্যবস্থাও এখন দূর্বৃত্তায়িত সেই ১৯৭২ থেকেই। রাষ্ট্রকাঠামো ও ধনীরা এখন একে অন্যকে ঠেকা দিচ্ছে। ক্ষমতা অজেয় হয়ে উঠেছে একই ব্যবস্থায়। কতোই কায়েমি হচ্ছে এই ব্যবস্থা  ততোই গণতন্ত্র দূরে সরে যাচ্ছে। মূলমন্ত্র হয়ে উঠেছে ধনী-দলীয় অাঁতাত।

রাষ্ট্রের প্রকৃতি এখন অসমতার বুনিয়াদে দাঁড়িয়ে অাছে। অার এভাবে যা অাসছে সেটাই এই অশুভ অাঁতাঁতের জন্য বোনাস। সরকার তাই ফাঁক যাই কিছু ধরা পড়ুক তাতে  নাক গলাবে না। 

• সূত্র - বুধবার, জানুয়ারি ১৭, ইংরেজি দৈনিক নিউ এইজে প্রকাশিত সাংবাদিক ও গবেষক অাফসান চৌধুরির লেখা অনুসারে।